Email Marketing

Stop Obsessing Over Email Open Rates. Here's What Actually Matters (And 12 Ways to Crush It)

Look, I get it. There's something damn satisfying about seeing those open rate numbers climb. It's like getting likes on your Instagram post. Feels good, but does it actually mean anything?

Here's the thing that took me way too long to figure out: open rates are basically the participation trophy of email marketing. Sure, someone opened your email, but so what? Did they actually do anything with it?

After years of chasing the wrong metrics and wondering why my email campaigns weren't converting prospects into actual clients, I finally had my "aha" moment. It's not about getting people to open your emails. It's about getting them to click through and take action. And once I shifted my focus to click-through rates (CTRs), everything changed.

Why Click-Through Rates Are Your Real MVP

Let me break this down for you in plain English. When someone clicks through your email, they're telling you something important: "This is interesting enough that I'm willing to leave my inbox and see what you've got."

That's engagement gold right there.

Open rates just tell you someone glanced at your subject line and thought, "Eh, might as well." But clicks? Clicks show intent. They show genuine interest. And most importantly, they show you've got a lead who's actually worth your time.

I learned this the hard way when I was sending out these gorgeous newsletters with 40% open rates but barely getting any actual inquiries. Turns out, people were opening them, skimming for two seconds, and moving on with their lives. Not exactly the result I was after.

12 Game-Changing Strategies That Actually Work

1. Write Subject Lines That Don't Suck (But Also Deliver)

This might sound contradictory since we're moving beyond open rates, but hear me out. Your subject line still matters, it's just not the end goal anymore.

The trick is writing subject lines that attract the right people, not just anyone with a pulse. Instead of clickbait-y nonsense like "You won't believe this!", try something that actually promises value:

• "Virtual tour: That 4-bedroom you've been waiting for"

• "Market update: Why now might be your moment"

• "Sarah, three new matches for your wish list"

The key? Whatever you promise in that subject line, you better damn well deliver in the email. Trust me on this one.

2. Make Your Emails Mobile-Friendly (Because Duh)

I cannot stress this enough: if your emails look like garbage on mobile, you're basically lighting money on fire. Over 60% of people check email on their phones, and that number keeps climbing.

This means big buttons, clean layouts, and text that doesn't require a magnifying glass to read. I made this mistake early on, wondering why my CTRs were so low. Turns out, my "gorgeous" desktop email templates looked like a hot mess on mobile.

3. CTAs That Actually Make People Want to Click

Here's where most people screw up: they write weak-ass calls-to-action that sound like they were written by a robot having a bad day.

Instead of "Click here for more information" (ugh), try something that sounds like a human wrote it:

• "Show me the virtual tour"

• "I want the market report"

• "Book my private showing"

See the difference? The second set actually sounds like something you'd say to a friend.

4. Stop Treating Everyone the Same

This one's huge. Sending the same email to a first-time buyer and a seasoned investor is like wearing the same outfit to a beach party and a business meeting. It might work, but it's probably not optimal.

Segment your list based on where people are in their journey:

• First-timers who need education

• Serious buyers ready to move

• Investors looking for deals

• Past clients who might refer

Each group needs different content, different tone, different everything.

5. Personalization Beyond "Hey [First Name]"

We've all gotten those emails that start with "Hey Sarah" and then launch into generic content that could apply to literally anyone. Don't be that person.

Use what you know about your subscribers:

• "Since you loved that craftsman-style home on Maple Street..."

• "New listings in [their preferred neighborhood]"

• "Market update for your price range"

It takes a bit more work, but the results are worth it.

6. Give People a Reason to Care

Every email should answer the question: "What's in it for me?" If you can't answer that in five seconds, your email probably sucks.

Instead of just pushing listings, provide value:

• Market insights they can't get elsewhere

• Home maintenance tips that save money

• Local event calendars

• First-time buyer guides

When you consistently provide value, people start looking forward to your emails instead of just tolerating them.

7. Use Social Proof (Because FOMO is Real)

People are sheep. I don't mean that in a bad way – it's just human nature to look at what others are doing and think, "Maybe I should do that too."

Use this to your advantage:

• "Join 500+ homeowners who found their dream home with us"

• "This property got 12 offers in 24 hours – here's why"

• Client testimonials with a "read more" link

8. Create Urgency Without Being Sleazy

There's a fine line between creating urgency and being that annoying salesperson who makes everything "urgent" and "limited time only."

Good urgency feels natural:

• Open house schedules

• Market conditions that won't last

• Limited spots for educational events

Bad urgency feels manipulative:

• Fake countdown timers

• Made-up deadlines

• Artificial scarcity

9. Design Emails That Don't Look Like Spam

Your email design can make or break your CTRs. Here's what I've learned works:

• Clean, simple layouts

• Plenty of white space

• High-quality images (with alt text!)

• Multiple CTAs throughout longer emails

• Clear hierarchy of information

Basically, make it easy for people to scan and find what they're looking for.

10. Test Everything (Seriously, Everything)

This is where the magic happens. I test subject lines, CTA buttons, email layouts, images – you name it. Even small changes can make a huge difference.

For example, I once tested "Explore New Listings" vs. "View New Homes" and the second one got 23% more clicks. Same content, different words. Wild, right?

11. Quality Over Quantity (Always)

I used to think more emails = more results. Wrong. Dead wrong.

It's better to send one really good email per week than five mediocre ones. People will start ignoring you if you become noise in their inbox.

Focus on:

• Consistent schedule (weekly works well)

• Clear purpose for each email

• Valuable content every time

12. Clean Your Email List Regularly

This one's not sexy, but it's crucial. If you're sending emails to dead addresses, fake emails, or people who never engage, you're hurting your deliverability.

Use tools like NeverBounce to clean your list regularly. Yes, your list might get smaller, but it'll be higher quality. And honestly? I'd rather have 500 engaged subscribers than 5,000 who ignore me.

What Success Actually Looks Like

Here's the thing about focusing on CTRs instead of open rates: it forces you to create better content. When you know people need to be interested enough to click, you can't just phone it in.

Track these metrics instead:

• Click-through rates (obviously)

• Conversion rates from clicks

• Revenue generated from email campaigns

• List health and engagement

When you’re ready, here’s how I can help:

AgentReach: Real Estate Email Marketing
Elevate your client communication with professionally designed, branded email campaigns created and delivered for you monthly. Let AgentReach handle your email marketing from start to finish.

Social Media Management
Get consistent, branded content posted 2-3 times weekly with professional video editing and content management. Click here to learn more.

Lead Generation
Stop chasing clients and start attracting qualified leads with targeted paid advertising management for real estate and mortgage professionals. Book your discovery call to create a customized lead generation plan that delivers results.

ADVERTISE WITH US

Interested in advertising in one of our newsletters?

Connect with Canadian agents who read The Modern Agent

Reach out to [email protected]